Best pizza in Kalamazoo

Having trouble ordering online, call in to 269-216-3651

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

14” Cheese Pizza

Hand stretched New York style 14 inch pizza.

Thai Signature Pizza

Peanut sauce, light mozzarella, red onion, red pepper, shaved carrots, pineapple, cilantro & sweet red curry sauce.

Pesto Signature Pizza

CONTAINS: Nuts Pesto, light mozzarella, artichokes, sun dried tomatoes, red onion, goat cheese & fresh basil when available. NOT AVAILABLE FOR VEGAN

Spicy Signature Pizza

Marinara, fresh jalapeno slices, jalapeno stuffed green olives, white onion, red pepper flakes & your choice of meat or extra veggie.

NY White

The White is a staple pizza in NYC. We're bringing it to Kzoo. It starts with our crust, of course, then starts with our garlic infused olive oil, ricotta, pecorino, shredded and fresh mozzarella and burrata cheese. After it's baked its topped with a drizzle of garlic infused olive oil and fresh basil (when available and not bonk). It is a cheese lovers DELIGHT!

Cheese Filled Garlic Knots (6)

6 Garlic Knots tossed in a blend of Parmesan and Romano cheese.

VEGAN Cheese Filled Garlic Knots (6)

6 Garlic Knots filled with vegan cheese.

Order From Our Website

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.
Order Now

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

What an amazing find. The staff was very welcoming. It was my 1st time there and they made you feel like family. Fresh ingredients they even grow their own mushrooms!!! One thing I truly love is that they were warm and welcoming one of the family members even shared a slice of their Pizza which I ended up ordering later on during my trip to Michigan.

Monique C.

Monique C.

First time eating here and definitely will not be the last. The food was fantastic and the owners, family and staff were so friendly and very welcoming. Best pizza we have had in a very long time.

Heather S.

Heather S.

I've been several times, just trying out different pizzas. I've only ordered the vegan options, but I absolutely love this place. The owner and staff are super friendly and helpful. The pizzas are great, not too thin or thick, not so many toppings that the pizza is soggy, it's been very consistent and I like that. My favorite so far has been the spicy vegan. If you're on the fence, I'd say give it a try!

Justin L

Justin L

Making Pizza with Mel!

Making Pizza with Mel!
Monday's in March from 6-8:30 pm. $50 per person over 12 years of age. Learn how to roll doughballs, stretch and possibly toss dough (if you're brave enough), sauce cheese and top pizza to your liking, and finally bake your own pizza. Soda and water are included, if you'd like to drink something more fun, BYO. Contact Melodie at pizzakaterinakzoo@gmail.com

Corporate Events - Team bonding experience!

Corporate Events - Team bonding experience!
Want to build better communication? Need to increase trust between colleagues or management and staff? Aim to bring lighter air into your working environment? These "tasks" can be worked in a way that supports those goals. Contact Melodie at pizzakaterinakzoo@gmail.com.

Who We Are

Who We Are
It all started when Paul and Kathleen decided to take their love of New York Style Pizza and bring it to Kalamazoo Michigan. Pizza Katerina was born! At the same time Melodie and Jimmy were working in their home to perfect their homemade pizza for family and friends to share. They had been working on their recipes for 8 years changing this and that for the best taste and texture.

Featuring

Catering

Gluten-Free Options

Healthy Options

Easy Parking

Vegan Options

Distinctive and Bold

Distinctive and Bold
Stop in for a couple slices of NY style pizza and a soda, or order a pizza to take home after work. While you are here check out our fresh baked breads on Tuesday, Thursday and Saturday. Whatever you choose, we promise to always strive for your satisfaction as we want to be more than a shop selling pizza. We want to be good neighbors and friends.

Always Fresh Ingredients

Always Fresh Ingredients
All of our pizza dough is made in house and stretched by hand. Our sauce is made from whole, peeled, California plum tomatoes with our own blend of herbs. All of our breads are made fresh using our own, tested recipes.
Pizza Katerina Rewards

Pizza Katerina Rewards

Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up to date with us.

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.
Order Now

Frequently asked questions

Our location